2007-11-27

Marty McWha?

Thought provocation time. Remember the scene in Back to the Future when Marty is jamming on the guitar in the 1952 prom? The injured guitar player is yelling into the phone to a fellow named Charles, and identifies himself as a cousin with the last name of Berry. So weren't meant to believe that notable rock guitarist Chuck Berry got his influence from future shredder Marty.

The problem is that the song Marty is playing, Johnny B. Goode, was popularized by Chuck Berry himself. So what we end up with is a circular reference. How could Chuck Berry influence himself? It's almost like Phillip J. Fry being his own grandfather! That's today's gaping plot hole in a Hollywood movie for you.

1 comment:

C said...

Spoiler Warning!

Meet the Robinsons commits this exact same mistake! The little boy inspires himself with knowledge from the future of inventions he has yet to create. And the movie implies that without that inspiration he wouldn't have made them. Circular I tell you!